As far as longevity, I feel it's a mixed bag. I still have a few of the songs on my playlists. Particularly Wild, Heart Stops, and Greater Than 84. As a whole album I don't really think it's their best work but I do feel it makes up for the only album by them I don't really care for, which as you can probably tell is December Underground. It's a a really good incorporation of all their previous work and a nice direction for the band. It may not be my favorite AFI album but it's up there and still worth the listen.
Read the original review here.